Treatment withdrawal: Should a child's parents or the court decide?

As news breaks that the Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Charlie Gard's parents, David Lawson examines the principles behind the best interests test
Charlie Gard has a rare genetic mitochondrial illness affecting in particular his brain, muscles, and ability to breathe. In October 2016, within two months of being born, he was admitted to Great Ormond Street Hospital experiencing lethargy and shallow breathing.
In December 2016, Charlie’s mother heard about a new treatment being administered to a child at a reputable medical centre in the US. Great Ormond Street contacted the US team and was told there was no direct evidence about the efficacy of this treatment for someone with Charlie’s condition but ‘theoretical and anecdotal evidence’ that it might help.
In January 2017, an application was made to the ethics committee for the treatment to be trialled in the UK. However, during January a very serious deterioration of Charlie’s condition led doctors to conclude that further treatment would be futile, only prolonging Charlie’s suffering.
Best interests application
Everyone reading this case is aware of the dedication of Charlie’s parents and the desperately difficult situation as recorded by both the High Court and the Court of Appeal.
Charlie’s parents raised over £1m so that he could be treated in the US. The disagreement between them and the hospital about whether to continue treatment and transfer Charlie abroad led to an application to the High Court to determine Charlie’s best interests.
The resulting judgment opens with this simple question and answer: ‘Some people may ask why the court has any function in this process, why can the parents not just make the decision for themselves? The answer is that, although the parents have parental responsibility, overriding control is by law vested in the court exercising its independent and objective judgment in the child’s best interests.’
Following a traditional best interests analysis, Mr Justice Francis concluded that the consensus medical view was that treatment would be ‘futile’. Declarations were made that treatment, other than palliative care, was not in Charlie’s best interests.
The judge’s question of parental authority was the basis of an appeal to the Court of Appeal. Charlie’s parents argued that the court could not prevent them arranging treatment for Charlie in the US, particularly from a reputable medical team, and that the court had no role using declarations to block parental decision making unless the child was at risk of ‘significant harm’.
Significant harm
As a matter of first principle, there is a conceptual clarity to the judge’s question, but in terms of statute law and case authority the appellants were on difficult ground. They argued that parents are in a privileged position of giving or withholding consent which could only be overridden if pursuit of their option would be likely to cause the child significant harm.













