Barriers to justice for injured victims
An inquiry into civil justice has revealed significant hurdles for genuine personal injury claims impacting victims' access to justice
An inquiry by the House of Commons Justice Committee has indicated that recent civil justice policies have complicated and in some cases rendered genuine personal injury claims economically unfeasible. The Association of Personal Injury Lawyers (APIL) has expressed approval for the committee's findings, stating that they bring important issues to the attention of the Government. Guy Forster, president of APIL, remarked that “The committee has firmly acknowledged the concerns we raised in evidence about what it describes as the ‘weaponisation’ of the rules on fundamental dishonesty by some defendants. The Government now has to consider a review, which is a very positive step forward.” He also noted the adverse effects caused by a failure to adjust fixed recoverable costs to align with inflation, an issue that the committee took into consideration.
The committee recommended a review of fixed recoverable costs to see if they reflect the actual expenses associated with litigation. Guy stated, “Our research shows that fixed costs have emerged as a significant barrier to access to justice for injured people,” adding that “Since 2013 there has been a 42 per cent rise in inflation, yet for many injured people the amount of legal costs they can recover from the wrongdoer has not increased at all.” He further elaborated that certain lawyers are unable to pursue claims on behalf of injured individuals or that victims end up shouldering the financial burden themselves, exacerbating the increasing "justice gap" where injured parties refrain from seeking redress.
Forster emphasised that “Redress is crucial for the best recoveries, rebuilding lives, and getting injured victims of negligence back to contributing to society.” In recent months, APIL has lobbied the Justice Committee regarding potential reforms to claims for NHS negligence, cautioning against the introduction of no-fault compensation schemes proposed by some groups. The committee conveyed its “highly sceptical” stance on such systems, while also asserting that “reducing avoidable injury offers the clearest route to controlling expenditure while improving outcomes for patients.” Forster concluded that “The committee has heeded our evidence and the needs of injured people. Many of the recommendations are helpful and, in some cases, point in the direction of righting.”












