Southern Water v Environment Agency: tribunal nearly halves £1m Herne Bay sewage penalty

First-tier Tribunal cuts variable monetary penalty to £525,000 after reassessing the EA's stepped approach.
Southern Water Services Limited has succeeded in reducing a £1 million variable monetary penalty (VMP) imposed by the Environment Agency over a sewage discharge in Herne Bay to £525,000. The First-tier Tribunal upheld the Agency's assessment of culpability and harm but disagreed with how the figure was reached.
In Southern Water Services Limited v The Environment Agency [2026] UKFTT 1562 (GRC), a panel chaired by Judge O'Connor, Chamber President, heard the appeal under paragraph 11 of Schedule 26A to the Environmental Permitting (England and Wales) Regulations 2016. The VMP regime, an alternative to prosecution, applies to offences committed in England on or after 1 December 2023.
The incident
On 23 March 2024 a pressurised PVC rising main split, releasing untreated sewage into highway gullies and then into the Bishopstone Glen watercourse, which flows about 300 metres into the sea. The coastline is protected by several conservation designations and was then a designated bathing water. The discharge continued for at least seven hours. Samples showed E. coli at 3.3 million cfu per 100ml at the point of discharge and 2.3 million at the beach mixing point, with ammonia at levels toxic to aquatic life, although no dead fish or invertebrates were found. Signs advising against bathing remained in place for around two days.
Southern Water accepted the offence under regulations 12(1)(b) and 38(1) but argued that culpability was low, harm fell within Category 3, and the appropriate penalty was £140,000.
Culpability and harm
The tribunal found the company negligent. A similar burst had occurred on the same rising main in December 2022, yet the operational continuity plan, dating from 2016, said nothing about the length of pipework needed for over-pumping. Only 40 of the 80 metres required arrived on the day, forcing a fallback plan of digging a sump and tankering from it. Over-pumping was not operational until about nine hours after staff first attended. The plan was updated to specify the extra pipework only in January 2026. The company's argument that tanker shortages during a period of high groundwater demand were the real constraint did not alter the conclusion.
On harm, the tribunal held that contamination along several hundred metres of watercourse, extending into the sea, was a significant adverse effect on water quality amounting to Category 2 of the Sentencing Council's environmental offences guideline. It also found a significant effect on bathing amenity. That the incident occurred outside the statutory bathing season was not material, since the season governs monitoring rather than whether people swim.
Calculating the penalty
For a large organisation, a negligent Category 2 offence carries a starting point of £140,000. Because Southern Water's turnover was around £992 million, the tribunal moved the starting point up to £350,000 to reflect its size. It then reduced it to £300,000 because the harm lasted only a short time.
Agreeing with Johnson J's recent sentencing remarks that 174 previous convictions dating back to 1990 were an exceptionally serious aggravating factor, the panel raised the figure to £700,000. Having regard to recent post-tax losses alongside a half-year profit, it was satisfied this was proportionate.
Although guilty plea credit does not apply to VMPs, the tribunal allowed a one-quarter reduction for prompt self-reporting and full, timely cooperation, arriving at £525,000.
The decision illustrates the tribunal conducting a full rehearing, applying the Agency's 12-step enforcement policy and the sentencing guideline afresh, with the appellant bearing the burden on the balance of probabilities.
Richard Banwell (Six Pump Court) for Southern Water; Richard Moules KC (Landmark Chambers) for the Environment Agency.
.png&w=3840&q=60)










