Marsh Lane (Leyton) LLP v Corporate Spec: flawed statutory declaration does not defeat 1954 Act contracting out

Lease exclusion upheld despite declaration errors, but landlord loses break clause and inflated damages claim.
A landlord has defeated a tenant's attempt to claim security of tenure under Part II of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954. However, it failed to rectify a break clause and failed in a claim for negotiating damages of £70,000 a month.
In Marsh Lane (Leyton) LLP v Corporate Spec Ltd [2026] EWHC 2931 (BP), Mark Anderson KC, sitting as a judge of the High Court, held that a renewal lease of an industrial unit in east London had been validly contracted out, despite defects in the tenant's statutory declaration.
The defendant, a furniture business, took an 18-month renewal lease from October 2024, which included a clause excluding sections 24 to 28 of the Act. The tenant argued that the exclusion was void under section 38A(3) because the warning notice had not been served on it and the statutory declaration was not "substantially in the form" required by the Regulatory Reform (Business Tenancies) (England and Wales) Order 2003.
The court rejected both arguments. Solicitors instructed in a conveyancing transaction usually have authority to accept service of notices connected with it, so emailing the notice to the tenant's solicitors was good service. In any event, the notice had reached the tenant's director, which was enough under UKI (Kingsway) Ltd v Westminster City Council [2019] 1 WLR 104. The judge added, obiter, that an estoppel by representation would also have prevented the tenant from denying service, distinguishing the estoppel by deed rejected at first instance in TFS Stores v Designer Retail Outlet Centres.
The declaration, drafted by the landlord's solicitor, contained a stray paragraph break that threw out its cross-references. Applying Chiltern Railway Co Ltd v Patel [2008] EWCA Civ 178 and the Court of Appeal's decision in TFS Stores [2021] EWCA Civ 688, the judge found this to be a technical defect with no substantive effect. The scanned copy the tenant returned omitted the warning notice, but the court found that the page had probably been left out when the declaration was scanned, not when it was made.
The landlord fared worse on the break clause. The definition of "Break Date" stated that it could not be earlier than 18 months from the date of the lease, which in practice made the rolling three-month mutual break unusable during the term. Correction by interpretation failed because the parties' intention could not be identified without looking at pre-contractual negotiations, so the second condition in Chartbrook Ltd v Persimmon Homes Ltd [2009] UKHL 38 was not met.
Rectification for common mistake also failed. Early emails recorded an agreed rolling break, but the landlord called neither its property manager nor its conveyancing solicitor to explain how the disputed words came to be included, and the judge found its two senior witnesses unreliable. The landlord had not proved that it had not changed its mind, and the tenant had probably been advised that the break was postponed. Unilateral mistake failed because the tenant was not obliged to share its privileged advice.
Damages for trespass therefore ran only from April 2026, when the term expired. The landlord sought negotiating damages reflecting lost rent after a planned refurbishment, saying it would have demanded £70,000 a month. The court rejected this on the facts, finding no settled intention to refurbish, and on the law. Relying on One Step (Support) Ltd v Morris-Garner [2018] UKSC 20, the judge held that negotiating damages value use of the property in its existing condition and cannot be used to recover unproven conventional losses, particularly without expert evidence.
The amount of mesne profits was left for further submissions after hand-down.












