Howarth v Austin: TCC rejects section 38 boundary presumption in neighbour's party wall claim

TCC holds section 38 LPA creates no boundary presumption and dismisses neighbour's party wall claim.
The Technology and Construction Court has dismissed a homeowner's trespass and nuisance claim over her neighbour's renovation of an adjoining Victorian terraced house, clarifying the limited role of section 38 of the Law of Property Act 1925 and casting doubt on any damages claim for breach of the Party Wall etc Act 1996.
In Howarth v Austin [2026] EWHC 2877 (TCC), HHJ Russen KC, sitting as a High Court judge, found that the defendant's 2024 works had not been shown to cause cracking in the claimant's property, and rejected her case on ownership of the walls.
The defendant, a property developer, removed internal walls, installed a steel picture frame, stripped plaster from the dividing wall and rebuilt a front garden wall. He accepted that the dividing wall, up to the roof of the claimant's rear extension, was a party wall.
Section 38 is not a presumption
Both party wall experts treated section 38 as presuming that a boundary runs through the centre of a party wall. The judge held this was wrong. The section addresses a wall that, under a disposition or arrangement, would before 1925 have been held by neighbours as tenants in common, and severs its legal ownership vertically. It therefore begs the question in a case where no conveyancing documents exist, and the term "party wall" in the 1925 Act cannot be read across to the 1996 Act definitions.
With no title deeds available, the boundary turned on historic maps and the physical features of the buildings. Drawing on Cantelmi v Hart [2016] UKUT 35 (TCC), the judge found that the boundary followed the claimant's side of the front garden wall, deviating only to give her the chimney breasts and flues. The front garden wall was not a party fence wall, despite the defendant's surveyor's earlier notice treating it as one.
Plaster and notification
The judge held that removing plaster from a party wall can amount to cutting into a party structure under section 2(2)(f), even with a hand tool rather than the percussive tools used in Kelliher v Ash Estates. Applying Grand v Gill, there was no cogent reason why plaster fixed to a wall should not form part of it. This was the only work requiring a party structure notice.
Causation and nuisance
The claimant relied on the "robust" approach to causation in Roadrunner Properties Ltd v Dean. The judge distinguished it, noting that Johnstone v Fawcett's Garage confirms it is an application of common sense rather than a reversal of the burden of proof. Here the expert evidence did not stop short. Uncontested calculations showed a 7.4% increase in foundation pressure, within accepted tolerances, and there was no diagonal settlement cracking. The judge rejected the claimant's engineer's late assertion of an "85% probability" of causation.
General anxiety about workmanship or fire risk did not found a nuisance claim unless the risk materialised. Increased noise from new occupiers fell within the "live and let live" principle in Fearn v Tate Gallery.
Breach of statutory duty
Although the claim had been abandoned by closing, the judge said, obiter, that no action for damages lies for failure to serve a party structure notice. Building on Power v Shah [2023] EWCA Civ 239, he reasoned that a building owner who chooses not to invoke the Act relies on common law rights and is exposed to trespass and nuisance claims. Section 3 is simply not engaged and cannot ground a separate tort.
Declarations as to party wall status and easements of support were refused as serving no useful purpose, and the claim was dismissed.











