Egan v Morgan: High Court upholds "score draw" costs ruling in boundary dispute

High Court dismisses appeal against no-order costs ruling in decade-long dispute over 45 square metres.
The High Court has dismissed an appeal against a decision to make no order as to costs in a boundary dispute over roughly 45 square metres of grass, scrub and trees. The litigation has run for a decade, and the appellant says she has spent more than £1m on legal fees.
In Egan v Morgan [2026] EWHC 2946 (BP), Mr Justice Tappin upheld the conclusion of Recorder Dagnall, sitting in the County Court at Maidstone, that the outcome was "something of a score draw" and that neither side was the successful party under CPR 44.2.
The proceedings began in 2016. Neil and Fiona Morgan sued their neighbour, Mary Egan, for damages after she removed a fence they had put up. Ms Egan counterclaimed. She said the boundary ran through the middle of a hedge between her field and the Morgans' garden, and she sought declarations, an injunction requiring the removal of a replacement fence, and damages for trespass.
At trial, unexpected evidence emerged of an earlier fence that neither party had pleaded as the boundary. In his substantive judgement of August 2022, the Recorder held that this earlier line was the true boundary and that parts of two of the Morgans' fences encroached by a few inches. Ms Egan was awarded £1,300 in damages and £1,300 in aggravated damages for trespass, and the Morgans' claim failed. The Recorder refused the injunction, however. He awarded £3,250 in lieu and declared the line of the existing fence to be the boundary. Apart from a limited order relating to a 2017 hearing, the resulting costs order of March 2025 made no order as to costs.
Richards J gave permission to appeal on three grounds. The first was that the Recorder wrongly treated the result as a draw. The second was that he wrongly required the Morgans' litigation conduct to have increased costs before it could count. The third, in the alternative, was that he failed to find that it had done so.
On the first ground, Ms Egan argued that she had won on remedies and that the Morgans were the party "writing the cheque", relying on Day v Day [2006] EWCA Civ 415. Tappin J rejected this. The Recorder had considered the pleaded issues and remedies, and it was wrong to look only at financial relief while ignoring Ms Egan's failure to obtain the non-monetary relief she had sought. Her case that the boundary lay in the middle of the hedge was central to her pleading, and she kept to it even after the evidence of the earlier fence emerged. The Recorder was entitled to take into account the non-monetary value to the Morgans of defeating that claim, and the refusal of the injunction. Applying Roache v News Group [1998] EMLR 161, the question was who had won in substance and reality, and the appeal court could not say that the Recorder's answer was wrong.
The conduct grounds also failed. Ms Egan relied on the first respondent's invective towards her solicitors and counsel's clerks, his disrespect towards judges and his abusive conduct towards court staff. Tappin J agreed that such behaviour was deplorable. However, he found nothing to suggest that the Recorder had departed from Widlake v BAA [2009] EWCA Civ 1256 and Walsh v Singh [2011] EWCA Civ 80. Under those authorities, sufficiently egregious misconduct may attract a proportionate costs penalty whatever its causative effect. The Recorder's handling of the 2017 hearing showed that he understood the principle. He had simply decided that the conduct did not merit particular weight.
Under ground 2B, Ms Egan pointed to voluminous correspondence, late evidence and unmeritorious points. Tappin J held that this was a generalised attack on the weight given to conduct, which Richards J had expressly excluded from the permission granted.
The judgement restates the high threshold for disturbing costs decisions set out in F&C Alternative Investments v Barthelemy [2012] EWCA Civ 843. It also confirms that where claims involve non-monetary relief, success is judged in the round, not simply by which party pays damages.












