BVD v Secretary of State for Defence: ARAP refusal quashed over unfair reconsideration

High Court quashes ARAP refusal after Ministry of Defence failed to correct applicant's known misunderstanding.
The High Court has quashed a decision refusing an Afghan former civil servant assistance under the Afghan Relocations and Assistance Policy (ARAP), finding that the Secretary of State for Defence acted unfairly by reversing an earlier favourable finding without warning the applicant that the issue was still live.
In BVD v Secretary of State for Defence [2026] EWHC 2990 (Admin), handed down on 18 November 2026, Mr Justice Johnson held that the Secretary of State knew the claimant was withholding representations on the determinative issue under a material misunderstanding, yet did nothing to correct it.
A reversal without warning
The claimant, who worked as a civil servant in Afghanistan for around 15 years, applied under ARAP in August 2021, relying on projects partly financed by the former Department for International Development (DFID). Category 4 requires an applicant to have worked alongside a UK Government department (Condition 1), to have made a substantive and positive contribution to UK military or national security objectives (Condition 2), and to face an elevated risk of targeted attack as a result (Condition 3).
His application was refused in 2023 and again on review in January 2025, each time on Condition 1. After a second judicial review claim was compromised, the Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office (FCDO) concluded that he had worked alongside DFID on a programme it had primarily funded and designed. In July 2025 the Defence Afghan Relocation and Resettlement team (DARR) accepted Condition 1 but refused the application on Condition 2.
The Secretary of State, having described Condition 2 as "the crux of the issue between the parties", withdrew that decision a week before the substantive hearing in May 2026. The claimant's further representations stated expressly that Condition 1 was no longer in dispute and addressed only Conditions 2 and 3. Nobody corrected that assumption. In June 2026, relying on unpublished FCDO standard wording emphasising regular personal contact with UK officials, DARR refused the application on Condition 1, without referring to the earlier contrary finding.
Fairness in practice
Johnson J accepted much of the Secretary of State's case. The July 2025 decision had been withdrawn in full, the consent order did not confine the reconsideration to Condition 2, and the decision-maker was entitled to revisit eligibility as a whole. There was no duty to disclose every provisional view or evidential concern, and the judge distinguished findings of dishonesty from assessments that evidence is insufficient, which will not invariably require a further opportunity to respond.
However, procedural fairness concerns the practical reality of the opportunity to make representations, not merely the formal scope of the decision-maker's power. The claimant's assumption, while perhaps unwise, was understandable given the history. The Secretary of State knew he was proceeding on a mistaken basis and ought to have appreciated its materiality. A short communication confirming that Condition 1 remained in issue, with a brief window for representations, would have sufficed.
The gravity of the consequences, the closure of ARAP to new principal applicants and a delay of almost five years reinforced that conclusion. Earlier opportunities to make representations were insufficient, since the favourable FCDO assessment post-dated them.
The decision was quashed, with the rationality ground left undetermined by agreement. Mandatory and declaratory relief was refused, as the claimant had not shown that the only lawful outcome was a decision in his favour. The Secretary of State must make a fresh decision as soon as practicable, after allowing representations on all applicable conditions.
The judgement confirms that a decision-maker free to revisit every issue may still need to say so when an applicant has plainly misunderstood the scope of reconsideration.











.png&w=3840&q=60)
