Abrahams v Business Insurance Solutions: High Court keeps South African workers' claim in England

High Court refuses to stay South African workers' conspiracy claim against English insurance broker.
The High Court has dismissed jurisdiction challenges brought by an English insurance broker and its former director, allowing 30 former South African call centre workers to pursue claims for economic torts and negligence in England.
In Abrahams & Ors v Business Insurance Solutions Ltd & Anor [2026] EWHC 2997 (KB), Karen Ridge, sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge, refused the broker's application for a stay on forum non conveniens grounds and the second defendant's application to set aside permission to serve him out of the jurisdiction.
The claimants were employed in South Africa by ConnectAQuote Pty Ltd (CAQ), which acted as appointed representative for Business Insurance Solutions Ltd (BISL) under an English law terms of business agreement (TOBA) on a cost-plus funding basis. In May 2023, shortly after employees raised a grievance over changes to their commission, BISL gave notice to terminate the TOBA. CAQ ceased trading and entered voluntary liquidation in July 2023.
The claimants allege that BISL, controlled from England, procured the non-payment of their remuneration and then made CAQ insolvent in retaliation for their South African labour claims. They plead unlawful means, conspiracy and negligence.
Availability of South Africa
Preferring the detailed expert evidence of a former South African Constitutional Court judge over letters from the defendants' attorneys, which were not Part 35 compliant, the judge held that a real and substantial connection would not by itself give the Western Cape High Court jurisdiction over foreign defendants. Submission was the only realistic route.
Applying Lubbe v Cape plc [2000] 1 WLR 1545, BISL's offer to submit made by the time of the hearing was sufficient to make South Africa available for the claim against it. However, following Vauxhall Motors Ltd v Denso Automotive UK Ltd [2025] EWHC 213 (Ch), the challenge to service out had to be assessed as at the date permission was granted. At that date the second defendant had made no offer to submit, so South Africa was not then available for the claim against him.
Appropriate forum
Adopting the holistic approach in Limbu v Dyson Technology Ltd, the judge found that the centre of gravity lay in England. The central issue was the control allegedly exercised by an English company over a South African one, and BISL was the anchor defendant. Most likely defence witnesses were in England, as were the key documents on the negotiation and operation of the TOBA.
Governing law carried limited weight: assuming South African law applied, without deciding the Rome II Article 4(3) "puppet master" argument, the relevant principles were agreed and similar. The conclusion held even if South Africa were available for both defendants.
Substantial justice
In the alternative, the claimants had shown by cogent evidence a real risk that substantial justice could not be obtained in South Africa. Their South African class action lawyer explained why no firm would act on a contingency basis, even if jurisdiction were established by submission. Applying Municipio de Mariana v BHP, the failure to test the market did not undermine that evidence. The risk arose not from funding differences alone but from the likely absence of representation in a claim requiring disclosure and argument on fraud, conspiracy and governing law. The prescription concern could be met by undertakings.
A separate full and frank disclosure challenge also failed, the claimants' solicitors having repeatedly sought clarity on who could accept service and disclosed the position to the court.
The judge emphasised that her conclusions concern jurisdiction only and do not determine the merits of the claims.












