Why are lawyers so depressed?
Lawyers' wellbeing statistics are not a good read and scientists are still piecing together the reasons why this should be so, explains Dr Bob Murray
Lawyers rank among the most depressed professionals. One in three of them contemplate suicide at least once a year and about 30 per cent suffer from clinical major depression. These are not good statistics. Something is very wrong.
I work with lawyers mostly, but also with physicians, architects, accountants and many other high-stress professionals.
I try to help them succeed whether they work in large or small firms. I listen to them – when I’m not giving a talk that is – because I want to know, and because that’s my job. Listening.
I am a scientist and a clinical psychologist and as both I am trained to search for the hidden commonalities that bind people together.
Sometimes that commonality is a symptom, and if that’s the case it’s sad. Overwhelmingly the symptom that I see in lawyers is anhedonia – the inability to find pleasure in everyday things, or sometimes pleasure and satisfaction in anything at all, even law.
Of course, lawyers are not always sad and by no means all of them suffer from anhedonia or from clinical depression, a condition that ranges from dysthymia (low-level depression) to untreatable major depressive disorder. But happiness does not seem to be their predominant trait.
Why should this be? Firstly, let me confess that as yet science has really no idea of what depression – of any kind – really is.
It’s defined more by its symptoms than by any biological origin, which makes it a syndrome (a collection of symptoms) rather than a disease.
Depression often manifests differently in men and women. Women tend to display the classical ‘depressive’ symptoms such as defeatism, despondency, sadness, a sense of failure, procrastination and indecisiveness.
In men it can show up as irritability, anger, bullying, aggression, alcoholism, suicidality (about 80 per cent of all suicides are male), blame of others, need for control, sexual harassment or serial infidelity.
Recently in the legal profession more men have been seen to have ‘female’ symptoms and women ‘male’ symptoms.
Forget the Prozac
What we do know is that it isn’t all down to serotonin (or any other single neurochemical) imbalance, so forget the Prozac.
What is it, then, about lawyers that makes law such a depressing profession?
About 30-40 per cent of depression is genetic in origin – inherited from parents or even grandparents.
That this should predispose professionals to the illness makes sense since most had one or more parents who were also in high-stress professions.
Professionals are generally more depressed than other workers (except for child care workers, police officers, firemen and farmers who top the depressive list).
Depression is also caused by childhood trauma or loss. The trauma might be poor attachment (perhaps caused by parents not being there for them enough because, like most professionals, they were too busy or distracted), physical, verbal or sexual abuse, parental discord or divorce or too high expectations.
In talking to lawyers, I find that few received praise as children for anything except success – especially on the sport field or in the classroom.
This emphasis on winning, competitiveness and academic achievement is a major cause of depression. Lack of well-rounded praise in childhood can lead to severe anxiety, depression and even PTSD.
Absence of satisfying relationships is a prime cause of depression. Lawyers are more prone to divorce than other professionals.
Marital separation causes heartache and suffering. For a significant number, the problem is compounded because lawyers whose parents were lawyers (or in other high-stress professions) are more likely to have suffered from the added trauma of parental divorce.
The original deep sense of loss often leads to an inability to form lasting and satisfying non-professional relationships as adults. When this happens there’s almost no easy way to escape the grip of the mood disorder.
Lawyers tend to be pessimistic. Partly this is because of their training – they are trained to see what is wrong, and partly – as several recent studies have shown – because they are genetically prone to pessimism.
Pessimism and depression are genetically closely linked. Depression is catching. Depression shares with pessimism one salient characteristic: it is catching!
The more you hang out with pessimistic or depressed people the more likely you are to be pessimistic or depressed.
Lawyers working with other lawyers – or socialising with other lawyers, or pessimistic and depressed clients – are bound to become more of both.
Lawyers and other professionals are over- stressed. The rate of chronic stress in the legal profession has been rising alarmingly over the last few years.
Many, many studies have shown that work stress is a prime cause of depression. Part of this stress is that partners and others in law firms are being asked to do ever more with less support.
They are being asked to work longer and harder and to bring in more revenue in a flat or declining market.
Lawyers increasingly see their profession becoming dominated by AI, new law and other disruptors.
They see Richard Susskind’s prophecy in his book ‘The End of Lawyers’ coming true – although the book my colleague Dr Alicia Fortinberry and I co-wrote, ‘Leading the Future, the Human Science of Law Firm Strategy and Leadership’, takes a different view.
The whole concept of being a lawyer – someone there primarily to offer legal advice – has recently come into question. Many members of the profession are profoundly worried about these developments.
Unsurprisingly, the rate of depression is increasing among law students. I believe that many would-be lawyers feel that much of the training that they are receiving in law schools is irrelevant to what their chosen field is becoming.
That would be a major stressor since it is very hard to concentrate and get the necessary high grades for something that you don’t believe has any relevance.
Each of these factors requires a different solution. There is no one answer to the syndrome – no magic bullet, no reliable pill or therapy which will work for all the myriad causes of depression and there may never be one.
The more we discover about depression the more complex it becomes. For lawyers that may not be good news.
If there is good news it’s that as the profession changes from a concentration on the facts of law and advice based on those facts to something else, something more relevant to the needs of the great majority of human beings, some of the stressors presently pressing on the profession may ease.
In the meantime, there are five ways that members of the legal profession can help themselves:
- Get out into nature more. Many studies have shown that nature is a marvellous antidepressant.
- Connect more with people who are not depressed or pessimistic. In practice this may mean working and socialising with non-lawyers more.
- Develop your spiritual side. Take up yoga, Tai Chi or meditation.
- Insist on getting praised for good work, and not just by clients – to get the reward neurochemical dopamine flowing. It will also make you smarter and more creative.
- Walk a lot – especially in nature and even more especially in the company of people who appreciate you.
In a later article I’ll look more closely at the best ways for lawyers to avoid and heal from this terrible mood disorder.
Dr Bob Murray is a behavioural psychologist with an interest in legal and professional services. For the latest on human behaviour and wellness, and how these relate to leadership and strategy, sign up for Dr Murray’s weekly newsletter ‘Today’s Research’ at fortinberrymurray.com