News EditorSolicitors Journal

Landmark ruling: electronically supplied software constitutes 'sale of goods' under Commercial Agents Regs

Landmark ruling: electronically supplied software constitutes 'sale of goods' under Commercial Agents Regs

Decision has significant implications for software resellers

In a landmark ruling today (16 September), the Court of Justice of the European Union has ruled the sale of electronically supplied software is a ‘sale of goods’ within the meaning of the Commercial Agents Regulations.

The decision has significant implications for the software industry and the reseller business model; IT lawyers will need to familiarise themselves with the judgment.

The court’s decision related to a dispute between Computer Associates UK Limited (Computer Associates) and The Software Incubator Limited (TSIL) over the termination of an agency contract.

Steve Sidkin, partner at Fox Williams, who represented TSIL, said: “This has been a long-running case, but we’re delighted with the Court of Justice’s decision. Although it has taken a long time, the Court of Justice’s decision confirms that Computer Associates wrongfully terminated its agreement with TSIL.

“Software companies both in the UK and EU which use resellers – in effect agents – will now need to consider their use. This has particular implications for the European subsidiaries of US software houses that use the reseller business model”.

He explained: “All software companies can now expect claims for compensation when their contracts with resellers come to an end for any reason other than a serious breach by the reseller”.

Sidkin said: “For resellers, the Court of Justice’s decision is to be welcomed as it clarifies that they are protected by the EU Agents Directive and the UK Commercial Agents Regulations”.

In 2013, TSIL agreed to promote Computer Associates’ automation software in the UK and Ireland, and were supplied electronically with a licence for use. Subsequently, TSIL also entered into a separate agreement with a competitor company, Intigua, under which it also agreed to promote and market Intigua’s software in the UK and Ireland.

Computer Associates subsequently alleged TSIL had breached obligations to devote "substantial time and effort" to its provision of services, and to not engage in any activity which competed directly with Computer Associates software. TSIL commenced proceedings against Computer Associates for damages for breach of contract and compensation under the Commercial Agents Regulations.

In the High Court, TSIL was awarded compensation, though this was later overturned on appeal, with the Court of Appeal ruling that electronically supplied software does not constitute “goods” within the meaning of the Commercial Agents Regulations.

In 2019, TSIL appeared before the Supreme Court which asked two questions of the Court of Justice of the European Union:

1. Does bespoke software supplied electronically (and not on any tangible medium) constitute “goods” for the purpose of the definition of a commercial agent?

2. Does bespoke software supplied to a principal’s customer under a perpetual licence constitute a sale of goods for the purpose of the definition of a commercial agent?

The Court of Justice ruled in favour of TSIL and confirmed the grant of a licence to use electronically supplied software constitutes a sale of goods.

Sidkin concluded: “Following this decision, software companies should now give thought to including provisions in their contracts with resellers which reduce the protection given by the Commercial Agents Regulations and the EU Agents Directive to resellers.”

AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement
Latest News

Legal job numbers increase but applications decline

Fri Sep 29 2023

BARBRI candidates outperform SRA average by 13%

Fri Sep 29 2023

Justice delayed as thousands of cases wait more than two years to be heard

Thu Sep 28 2023

Solicitors warned over immigration services

Thu Sep 28 2023

New report highlights the transformative effects of domestic abuse training on family lawyers

Wed Sep 27 2023

Asylum seekers stranded on Diego Garcia win challenge against return to Sri Lanka

Wed Sep 27 2023

UN and coalition of NGOs write to Unilever to voice deep concern regarding victims of violence at Unilever tea plantation

Tue Sep 26 2023

Live Facial Recognition: How to Stay Within the Law

Tue Sep 26 2023

Ethics Institute launches taskforce to examine legal services to oligarchs and kleptocrats

Mon Sep 25 2023
FeaturedThe Law Society intervention ensures liberal approach to dealing with concurrent problems on legal aid
The Law Society intervention ensures liberal approach to dealing with concurrent problems on legal aid
Jeanne Kelly elected President of the British Irish Chamber of Commerce
Jeanne Kelly elected President of the British Irish Chamber of Commerce
Families continue to be victims of a broken justice system
Families continue to be victims of a broken justice system
Call for compensation scheme extension to help more abuse survivors
Call for compensation scheme extension to help more abuse survivors
SJ Interview: Hannah Ambrose
SJ Interview: Hannah Ambrose
Whose human rights are more important, yours or mine?
Whose human rights are more important, yours or mine?