Sign Up for our Free Newsletter
menu
Solicitors Journal Homepage
  • Home
  • News
  • Digital Edition
  • Practice Notes
    • Area of Law
      • Agricultural
      • ADR & Mediation
      • Asylum & Immigration
      • Aviation
      • Bankruptcy and Insolvency
      • Charities
      • Children
      • Clinical negligence
      • Commercial
      • Competition
      • Construction
      • Conveyancing
      • Costs
      • Crime
      • Data Protection
      • Discrimination
      • Education
      • Employment
      • Energy
      • EU
      • Expert witness
      • Family
      • Financial services & Tax
      • Health & Safety
      • Human rights
      • Inquest
      • Insurance
      • Intellectual property
      • Legal Aid
      • Litigation
      • Maritime
      • Media
      • Mergers & Acquisition
      • Pensions
      • Personal injury
      • Police & Prisons
      • Private client
      • Procedures
      • Professional negligence
      • Property
      • Public Law
      • Regulation
      • Residential
      • Road traffic
      • Vulnerable Clients
    • Management
      • Business Development and Marketing
      • Career development
      • Covid-19
      • Education & Training
      • Equality & diversity
      • Ethics and Compliance
      • Finance
      • Human Resources
      • Knowledge management
      • Leadership
      • Legal services
      • Marketing
      • Pro bono
      • Professional indemnity
      • Regulators
      • Risk & Compliance
      • Technical legal practice
      • Technology
      • Wellbeing
  • Opinion
  • Business
  • International
  • Interview
  • More
    • About
    • Contact Us
    • Subscribe
    • Newsletter
    • FAQ
    • Guide to Authors
    • Media Pack
    • Site Map
  • Contact Us
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Follow us:
    Twitter
    LinkedIn
© 2023 Solicitors Journal in partnership with the International In-house Counsel Journal | Picture Credits: Freepix, Unsplash and by permission of the authors
Alec Samuels

Alec Samuels

Barrister
Quotation Marks

“The parents sued the university for damages, and succeeded on the basis of indirect discrimination by unfavourable treatment by reason of her disability”

How far is the university legally liable for the students?

Wed Aug 24 2022Practice Notes
How far is the university legally liable for the students?

 

Alec Samuels looks at when universities should provide support for students on the premises

How far is the university legally liable for the students, apart from the usual duty of care as the owner occupier of the university premises and the usual duty of care of any institution and its people to the invitees? After all, the students are adults, 18 and over, and normally disgustingly healthy and fit. 

However, this is not the full picture: Abrahart v University of Bristol, HHJ Alex Ralston, 20 May 2022. The female student, studying physics in her second year, was required as part of the course and examination to give an oral presentation to the tutor and fellow students in a large lecture hall. 

She was an able student, who had been doing well, though recently falling off, grades in performance declining. She was shy, especially with authority, vulnerable, and was diagnosed with chronic social anxiety depressive disorder, and had been receiving mental health medical assistance, known to the university. The impending oral presentation subjected her to severe psychological trauma. 

A little before the presentation was due, she took her own life.

Damages

The parents sued the university for damages, and succeeded on the basis of indirect discrimination by unfavourable treatment by reason of her disability, of which the university knew or should have known, under the Equality Act 2010; damages £50,000.

Exam anxiety is not uncommon. Most of us, if we are honest, can remember and must admit to such experience, albeit perhaps a good many years ago now. The pressures were on to get the degree, to do well, to improve our chances in life. 

The students, young adults, may not be quite so mature and capable as they may like to think themselves. The evidence was that on average some half a dozen students in the university took their own lives year by year. For many it appears that, despite appearances, students do suffer considerable stress, to greater or lesser degree. 

So where does the university stand? Must it make a risk assessment in respect of every student? Maintain a watching brief? Ensure that there is an active and watchful personal tutor appointed to every student? Maintain a medical and psychiatric and psychological service in the university? Require an annual medical test? Keep the parents of the adult student informed of the progress of the student? The university is essentially an educational institution, not a medical or psychiatric institution. 

Causes of concern

Mental health problems of all kinds are very common throughout society; though often not readily visible. In difficult social and economic times the pressure to get a degree, and a good degree, can be considerable. The covid-19 pandemic and seriously interrupted teaching in the university world has further damaged higher education. 

In Abrahart, the university was aware of the difficulty imposed upon the student. She had even exhibited something of a suicidal disposition. The presentation causing the anxiety could have been organised in a smaller setting, with a smaller audience, or perhaps without an audience at all.

So, the university does owe a duty of care to the student. The student pays £9,250 a year for the experience. The student does have vulnerabilities, does suffer stress, especially from the examining activities. 

There should be a regular risk assessment, a personal tutor and a proper professional awareness of the potential problems of the course and indeed university life generally. Parents may need to be included, maybe very much against the wish of the student. Reasonable care must be taken. 

The teaching scholar may need to be trained in the discharge of the responsibility of the personal tutor in the modern world, a new care competency. The exam system itself may need fundamental rethinking and refashioning. And the law professional schools and the Inns of Court and the Law Society will surely be included. 

Alec Samuels is a barrister

Tags:
AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement
Latest News

Parents and carers to be given new employment protections

Fri May 26 2023

Committee finds plans to level up the country risk failure due to funding concerns

Fri May 26 2023

Government consults on enforcement mechanisms for animal health and welfare offences

Fri May 26 2023

Government expands legal aid eligibility

Thu May 25 2023

Council of Europe identifies serious concerns affecting minorities in the UK

Thu May 25 2023

ONS finds international migration to the UK hit new high in 2022

Thu May 25 2023

Government consults on plans to reduce reporting burdens on businesses

Wed May 24 2023

Committee report finds government not taking harms from alcohol seriously enough

Wed May 24 2023

Committee seeks views on the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Bill

Wed May 24 2023
Featured
A closer look at the trademark dispute between retail giants Lidl and Tesco
FeatureThu May 18 2023
A closer look at the trademark dispute between retail giants Lidl and Tesco

Angela Jack dissects the recent ruling in Lidl Great Britain Ltd & others v Tesco Stores Limited & others [2023] EWHC 873 (Ch)

The UK maternity care crisis: £5bn in avoidable damages claims
FeatureThu May 18 2023
The UK maternity care crisis: £5bn in avoidable damages claims

Billions of pounds in NHS damages claims could have been avoided had recommendations from past reviews been followed by action, argues Kerstin Scheel

Understanding Chinese underground banking and the risks
FeatureThu May 18 2023
Understanding Chinese underground banking and the risks

Laurence Howland explores the mechanisms of Chinese underground banking and the red flags

The building blocks for a successful collaborative culture
FeatureThu May 18 2023
The building blocks for a successful collaborative culture

Chris Marston explores the ways in which law firms can establish a powerful collaborative culture

SJ Interview: James Fulforth
SJ InterviewThu May 18 2023
SJ Interview: James Fulforth

The Solicitors Journal spoke to James Fulforth, Kingsley Napley’s newly appointed Senior Partner, about his experiences in the law, his thoughts on the UK’s tech sector and what he hopes to achieve in his new role

Long-awaited reports and controversial bills dominate
ForewordTue Apr 25 2023
Long-awaited reports and controversial bills dominate

Sophie Cameron takes a look at the news in the April Foreword