High Court Paves Way for Diesel Emissions Scandal Claims

14 Dec 2023News

Court allows progress in major car emissions scandal

The High Court's recent decision regarding legal claims against leading car manufacturers - notably Mercedes and two others - marks a significant step forward in addressing the diesel emissions scandal. With over 1.2 million vehicle owners involved, this ruling sets the stage for what could potentially become a groundbreaking trial by February 2025.

Amidst concerns over the complexity and overlap of legal issues in the massive group claims, the High Court conducted a decisive one-day hearing on 8 December. This aimed to streamline the management of claims, reduce costs, and optimize court resources.

Presided over by Dame Victoria Sharp, the hearing concluded that Mercedes will lead the Group Litigation Order (GLO) process, accompanied by two additional lead GLOs related to separate emissions cases. The aim is to efficiently resolve common legal and factual matters, streamlining the litigation process for other involved manufacturers.

To further streamline proceedings, a three-day consolidated hearing is scheduled for 17-19 January 2024. This will address all existing and potential GLO applications related to the claims. Lawyers representing the vehicle owners emphasized that designating Mercedes as the lead claimant could expedite the resolution of shared legal and factual issues across other emissions cases.

Additionally, the court directed parties to collaborate in agreeing on terms for sharing confidential information across the various claims before the January 2024 hearings. Disputes regarding confidentiality will be addressed in a Case Management Conference on 19 January 2024.

Martyn Day, senior partner at Leigh Day, expressed satisfaction with the High Court's decision to propel the emission claims forward without undue delay. He highlighted the manufacturers' apparent aim to stall proceedings and expressed hope that resolving these claims may occur within the next few years.

The emissions claims involve a wide array of vehicle manufacturing groups, including Mercedes, Volkswagen, Ford, BMW, and others. Several law firms representing the claimants, including Leigh Day and Pogust Goodhead, jointly presented at the hearing, collectively representing over 1.2 million affected individuals.

Legal News desk contact: editorial@solicitorsjournal.com

Latest Articles

When pets become a family law issue

As pet ownership rises, family law struggles to reconcile animals’ sentience with their continued treatment as property

Shipping cartel settlement approved for consumers

The Competition Appeal Tribunal has finalised a £92.75 million settlement for affected vehicle purchasers

Consultation launched for housing offences

The Sentencing Council is inviting public input on new sentencing guidelines for housing offences

Abraaj Investment Management v Kes Power: Commercial estoppel and the assignment of receivables

High Court validates security assignment despite technical flaws through estoppel by convention principles.

Director of Public Prosecutions v Boureanu: Confiscation orders and the meaning of conviction

Romanian confiscation order enforced despite limitation preventing custodial sentence following corruption conviction.

Odusanya v Pennine Care Foundation Trust: witness evidence discussions and the right to representation

Strike-out appeal partially allowed where claimant denied consultation with representative during proceedings.

Smithstone v Tranmoor Primary School: Court of Appeal clarifies Part 36 costs in settled claims

90:10 liability offers viable but require actual determination to trigger enhanced costs

Network Rail Infrastructure Limited v Karl List: Advertising rights and railway hereditaments

Court of Appeal clarifies rating liability for advertising sites within operational railway stations under business rates legislation.

Cubic Transportation Systems v Transport for London: High Court lifts automatic suspension in £800m procurement challenge

TfL revenue collection contract dispute demonstrates adequacy of damages in major infrastructure procurement challenges.

Ioan Mailat v Hunedoara City Court: European arrest warrant particularisation requirements

High Court clarifies when missing offence details constitute wholesale failure in conviction warrants

High Court allows trial against Dyson

A High Court ruling sets the stage for a trial next year regarding claims against Dyson companies

Home Secretary gains power to dismiss chief constables

Under the new laws, Home Secretaries will gain statutory authority to force the retirement, resignation, or suspension of chief constables based on their performance

Hogan Lovells reveals bribery outlook 2026

Global law firm Hogan Lovells has launched its Bribery, Investigations & Enforcement Outlook report for 2026 focusing on emerging trends in compliance for multinational organizations

Limbu v Dyson: High Court orders liability trial for migrant workers' exploitation claims

Split trial approved over preliminary issues in Malaysian factory conditions case

Phullar v Ofsted: Employment tribunal failures in disability discrimination and unfair dismissal appeal

Dismissal for capability during cancer recovery raised procedural and reasonable adjustment failures throughout.

SJ Interview: Joelle Grogan

Dr Joelle Grogan is a legal scholar specialising in the rule of law in times of crisis. She presents The Law Show on BBC Radio 4, and is Co-Academic Director of the Rule of Law Clinic at the CEU Democracy Institute (Budapest), and a Senior Research Fellow at the UCD Sutherland School of Law. Her work focuses on constitutional accountability, emergency powers, and legal misinformation. In this interview, she examines the pressures facing the rule of law in the UK, from executive power and court delays to media narratives, emergencies, and the impact of AI on legal practice.

Justice reform risks targeting the wrong fix

As 2026 approaches, ministers eye jury trials while ignoring deeper causes of England’s criminal justice crisis