Lawtons
Quotation Marks

The Nightingale courts haven’t touched the side of the backlog to date

Covid-19 and the criminal courts: Investment is the key

Covid-19 and the criminal courts: Investment is the key

Nick Titchener, director and defence solicitor at Lawtons Law, explains what's needed to get the CJS back on its feet

The UK’s criminal justice system faces long-term damage because of numerous case delays combined with further difficulties caused by the pandemic. 

The court system, which has been described by the chair of the Criminal Bar Association (CBA) James Mulholland as being “on its knees”, has been hit hard by the pandemic with the backlog of unprocessed criminal cases exploding exponentially since the start of Covid-19. It has reached 54,000.

There are technological developments which are being used to cope with the unprecedented issues faced by the criminal justice system.

The use of the new cloud video platform (CVP) in hearings allows cases to be dealt with remotely without the physical attendance of prosecutors, defence advocates and witnesses in the court building.

Although intended primarily as a safety measure during the pandemic, it opens up the possibility of bringing new efficiency to the system in future. 

On occasions, defendants have also not been required to attend court in person and can take part in trials or certain hearings via video link from police stations, prisons, solicitors’ offices –and even their own homes. 

The difficulty of gathering all involved parties in one place is itself a factor in court delays, so virtual hearings like those on the CVP should, at least, help to ease the backlog. But they are not enough in themselves to fix the problem.

Many court buildings were built during a time when the justice system worked completely differently. Today, they are ill-equipped for social distancing, making them incompatible with the requirements for a covid-safe trial.

In order to provide the privacy and security needed and have a physically present jury, several rooms may be needed for any one trial.

But there are ways in which the backlog of cases and complications with old court buildings can be dealt with. The system must also undergo significant change.

There are a number of hopeful signs that new post-covid-19 ways of working could help ease the backlog, even though it still sits in the tens of thousands. That includes more efficient video conferencing, the prioritising of vaccines for jurors and the Nightingale courts set up in the middle of the pandemic.

However, it will take much more than this to solve the problem for good – and proper investment is key. 

The Nightingale courts (otherwise known as Blackstone courts) haven’t touched the side of the backlog to date. Few if any have been utilised effectively to alleviate the backlog or address the lack of suitable infrastructure.

Ultimately, though, the only way of resolving the crisis facing the CJS will be through a system of investment and planning which acknowledges the failures of past governments to modernise and adapt progressively and proactively.

Nick Titchener is a director and defence solicitor at Lawtons Law 

AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement
Latest News

UN and coalition of NGOs write to Unilever to voice deep concern regarding victims of violence at Unilever tea plantation

Tue Sep 26 2023

Live Facial Recognition: How to Stay Within the Law

Tue Sep 26 2023

Ethics Institute launches taskforce to examine legal services to oligarchs and kleptocrats

Mon Sep 25 2023

Legal Departments See Higher Matter Volumes but Flat or Declining Budgets: Thomson Reuters 2023 Legal Department Operations Index

Mon Sep 25 2023

More Than 200 Employers Named And Shamed For Failing To Pay National Minimum Wage

Mon Sep 25 2023

Browne Jacobson collaborates with LGiU on report highlighting “critical” role of local government to hit net zero

Fri Sep 22 2023

BSB publishes new guidance on barristers’ conduct in non-professional life and on social media

Fri Sep 22 2023

The Chancery Lane Project expands to the USA

Thu Sep 21 2023

Delay in Final Report of the Infected Blood Inquiry

Thu Sep 21 2023
FeaturedNew report highlights the transformative effects of domestic abuse training on family lawyers
New report highlights the transformative effects of domestic abuse training on family lawyers
Asylum seekers stranded on Diego Garcia win challenge against return to Sri Lanka
Asylum seekers stranded on Diego Garcia win challenge against return to Sri Lanka
A solicitor’s stance on EDI in the workplace
A solicitor’s stance on EDI in the workplace
New UK data protection bill may lighten the burden for business
New UK data protection bill may lighten the burden for business
SJ Interview: Hannah Ambrose
SJ Interview: Hannah Ambrose
Whose human rights are more important, yours or mine?
Whose human rights are more important, yours or mine?