Court highlights planning challenges in Folkestone

In a significant ruling, the High Court recently addressed the planning application case involving Folkestone and Hythe District Council and the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government, following the appeal decision for a redevelopment project in Folkestone. This case rests on key aspects of planning law, focusing on the interpretation of local policies, living conditions for future occupants, and the extent of planning permissions granted concerning ecological considerations.

The case originated with the Second Defendant's application for planning permission to redevelop the site known as The Old Laundry, located on Bowen Road, Folkestone. The development aimed to provide three one-bedroom flats. Despite the application including various supporting documents, including a preliminary ecological appraisal, the local planning authority, Folkestone and Hythe District Council, refused planning permission on the grounds that the proposed development fell short of the required internal space standards and did not provide acceptable levels of amenity space for future occupants.

The inspector appointed by the Secretary of State later upheld an appeal from the Second Defendant, allowing the planning permission based on a review of the council's objections. The council, aggrieved by the inspector's conclusions, sought judicial review, citing several grounds of challenge relating to the adequacy of the inspector's reasoning.

During the judicial review, the council's arguments pivoted around six key grounds. Firstly, it was contended that the inspector failed to address one of the critical issues concerning the outlook for future occupants of Flats 1 and 2. The council argued that the inspector misunderstood local planning policies and improperly assessed amenity considerations, which undermined the decision.

The focus of the proceedings was not only on the right to planning but also on broader issues, such as ensuring a high quality of living conditions for future residents. The description of necessary living space and amenity standards in local policies came under scrutiny alongside the requirements for biodiversity conditions to preserve ecological aspects of urban development.

Ultimately, the court found that the inspector's conclusions were sufficiently robust and within his jurisdiction. It acknowledged that planning policies, including those alleging internal space standards, could be interpreted flexibly, aligning with broader national objectives around housing. Notably, the judge underscored the inspector's analyses without requiring undue scrutiny. It was determined that the inspector adequately considered the council’s concerns regarding living conditions, as well as the absence of balconies in the flats due to privacy concerns.

While the council sought additional biodiversity and landscaping conditions, the court endorsed the inspector's rationale. The judge noted that the inspector's interpretation of the ecological reports and the conditions imposed were sensible and reasonable. The conclusion specified that the council’s requests for additional conditions were not necessary.

The ruling appears to reinforce the discretion afforded to planning inspectors when evaluating applications and determining the significance of challenges raised by local authorities. Consequently, the court rejected the grounds submitted by Folkestone and Hythe District Council, affirming the planning permission granted to the Second Defendant.

This case serves as a pertinent example of the evolving landscape of planning law in the United Kingdom, highlighting the balance sought between development aspirations and maintaining satisfactory living conditions for future occupants amidst ecological considerations. The implications for future planning applications may be profound, emphasising the need for local authorities to base their challenges clearly on substantive and compelling grounds to navigate the complexities of planning decisions.

Copyright & permissions