Editor, Solicitors Journal

British Chiropractic Association drops libel action

15 Apr 2010News

The British Chiropractic Association (BCA) has abandoned its libel action against science writer Simon Singh, following his outspoken comments in an article for The Guardian.

The British Chiropractic Association (BCA) has abandoned its libel action against science writer Simon Singh, following his outspoken comments in an article for The Guardian.

Dr Singh said there was 'not a jot of evidence' that members of the BCA, who are well known for dealing with back problems, could help tackle complaints such as sleeping disorders and asthma and claimed the organisation 'happily promotes bogus treatments'.

Mr Justice Eady's ruling that Singh could not rely on the defence of fair comment was overturned by the Court of Appeal earlier this month, presided over by the Lord Chief Justice, Lord Judge (see Solicitors Journal 154/14, 13 April 2010).

In a statement, a spokesman for the BCA said the association had decided to discontinue its libel action against Singh.

'As previously made clear, the BCA brought the claim because it considered that Simon Singh had made a serious allegation against its reputation, namely that the BCA promoted treatments that it knew to be 'bogus',' he said.

'The Honourable Mr Justice Eady, the UK's most experienced defamation judge, agreed with the BCA's interpretation of the article and ruled that it made a serious factual allegation of dishonesty.

'The Court of Appeal, in its recent judgment, has taken a very different view of the article. On its interpretation, the article did not make any factual allegation against the BCA at all; it was no more than an expression of 'honest opinion' by Simon Singh.

'While it still considers that the article was defamatory of the BCA, the decision provides Dr Singh with a defence such that the BCA has taken the view that it should withdraw to avoid further legal costs being incurred by either side.

'As those who have followed the publicity surrounding this case will know, Simon Singh has said publicly that he had never intended to suggest that the BCA had been dishonest. The BCA accepts this statement, which goes some way to vindicating its position.'

Legal News desk contact: editorial@solicitorsjournal.com

Latest Articles

UK lawyers forecast significant AI savings

UK lawyers anticipate artificial intelligence will generate £2.4 billion in productivity savings over the coming year

Estate agents need regulation for reforms

The CLC supports estate agent regulation to enhance home buying, warning reforms will falter without it

Government seeks thousands of new magistrates

The UK Government has launched a campaign calling for volunteers to become magistrates and help deliver justice across communities

Generative AI in law: opportunity, risk and responsibility

AI promises efficiency in legal practice, but unchecked use risks errors, sanctions, and damage to public confidence

EU moves to reset medical devices regulation

The Commission proposes structural reforms to stabilise, simplify and future-proof the EU medical devices regulatory framework

Why UK paternity leave still fails families

The UK’s paternity leave framework lags Europe, undermining families, equality and long-term economic resilience

Agent signatures fail for trust declarations

Court of Appeal rules that declarations of trust over land must be personally signed to satisfy statutory formalities

The UK anti-corruption strategy: pillar one in focus

How the UK’s latest Anti-Corruption Strategy seeks to disrupt corrupt networks, incentivise whistleblowers, and strengthen enforcement

CD&R Galaxy UK Opco Limited fined £33,438

CD&R Galaxy UK Opco Limited has agreed to a financial penalty and investigation costs following regulatory breaches identified by the Solicitors Regulation Authority.

Using US discovery to support English litigation

How Section 1782 offers a powerful, underused route to obtain US-based evidence for foreign proceedings

FCA priorities and predictions for 2026

A forward-looking assessment of the FCA’s recent focus and what FS regulatory lawyers can expect in the year ahead

Why judge-only trials won’t fix court backlogs

Proposals to curb jury trials risk fairness, worsen delays, and ignore the real causes of Crown Court backlogs

Regulatory progress under Martyn’s Law

Ronnie Megaughin reflects on his experience as Interim Executive Director and shares the important developments made in the regulation of Martyn’s Law over the past six months

International taskforce unveils bribery indicators

The Serious Fraud Office and Five Eyes nations release guidance to identify foreign bribery indicators for businesses

Government appoints interim commissioners to EHRC

The Government has appointed Ali Harris and Professor Shazia Choudhry as interim commissioners at the EHRC while new commissioners are recruited

SJ Interview: Joelle Grogan

Dr Joelle Grogan is a legal scholar specialising in the rule of law in times of crisis. She presents The Law Show on BBC Radio 4, and is Co-Academic Director of the Rule of Law Clinic at the CEU Democracy Institute (Budapest), and a Senior Research Fellow at the UCD Sutherland School of Law. Her work focuses on constitutional accountability, emergency powers, and legal misinformation. In this interview, she examines the pressures facing the rule of law in the UK, from executive power and court delays to media narratives, emergencies, and the impact of AI on legal practice.

Justice reform risks targeting the wrong fix

As 2026 approaches, ministers eye jury trials while ignoring deeper causes of England’s criminal justice crisis